12 Hidden Things That Raise Your Car Insurance (Not Driving)

Sarah Mitchell

Sarah Mitchell writes about insurance basics and consumer comparisons. Insurance enthusiast 12 years. Texas-based.

Visual representation of the voice · not a photographic portrait

Quick answer: Besides your driving record, insurers price your policy using your credit-based insurance score (in most states), your ZIP code, the exact car you drive, how many miles you drive, any gap in coverage, your claims history (even small claims), your age and marital status, and how you pay. Several of these you can change, so shop and update your details at least once a year.↗ Share on X

Your driving record is only one piece of your auto insurance price. Insurers also look at your credit-based insurance score (in most states), where you park the car, the exact model you drive, how many miles you drive, whether you ever let your coverage lapse, past claims even when they were small, and personal details like age and marital status. Many people with a spotless record pay more than they should because one of these hidden factors is working against them. The good news: you can change or correct several of them.

Below are 12 factors, what each one means in plain words, and what you can do about it.

Which hidden factors matter most?

READ ALSOTerm Life With a Health Condition: How Approval Really Works →Fender Bender? When Your Deductible Applies and Who Pays →How to Pick an Insurance Deductible You Can Really Afford →

Every insurer uses its own formula, and the rules change by state. Still, these are the factors that show up again and again.

1. Why does my credit affect my car insurance?

In most states, insurers use a credit-based insurance score. It is not the same as your regular credit score, but it uses similar information: on-time payments, how much debt you carry, and how long you have had credit. Insurers say people with stronger scores tend to file fewer claims, so they charge them less.

A few states, including California, Hawaii and Massachusetts, do not allow insurers to use credit this way for auto rates. Rules in other states vary.

What to do:

1. Pay every bill on time. Late payments hurt the most.

2. Keep credit card balances low compared with your limits.

3. Check your credit reports for free at AnnualCreditReport.com and dispute any mistakes.

4. After your credit improves, ask your insurer to re-check your score, or get new quotes.

2. Does my ZIP code really change my price?

READ ALSOInsurance Policy Lapse: What Happens and How to Get Covered →Will Switching Life Insurance Policies Lower Your Payout? →Does a Higher Deductible Really Lower Your Car Insurance? →

Yes. Two drivers with the same car and the same record can pay very different prices just because they live a few miles apart. Insurers look at how often cars in your area are stolen, broken into, or involved in crashes, and at local repair and medical costs.

You probably won't move to save on insurance. But make sure the address on your policy is correct. If you moved and never updated it, you may be paying for the wrong area, and a wrong address can cause trouble if you ever file a claim.

3. Is my car model costing me money?

The car itself matters a lot. Insurers check:

• Repair cost. Cars with expensive parts, sensors in the bumpers or cameras in the windshield cost more to fix after a small crash.
• Theft risk. Some models are stolen more often than others.
• Safety record. How well the car protects people in a crash affects the injury part of your policy.
• Engine power. Faster cars are often priced higher.

What to do: before you buy your next car, get insurance quotes for the two or three models you are considering. The difference can change which car is really cheaper to own.

4. How many miles do you actually drive?

Many people guessed their mileage years ago and never updated it. If you now work from home, retired, or changed jobs, you may be driving far less.

1. Look at your odometer today and write down the number.

2. Check it again one month later.

3. Multiply the difference by 12 to estimate your yearly miles.

4. Call your insurer and give them the new number.

If you drive very little, ask about a pay-per-mile or usage-based program. These track your driving through an app or a small device. Be honest with yourself: if you often brake hard or drive late at night, these programs may not help you.

5. Did you ever have a gap in coverage?

Even a short time without insurance, such as when you sold one car and waited to buy another, can raise your price. Insurers see a lapse as a sign of higher risk.

What to do: if you will be without a car for a while, ask about a non-owner policy. It is usually cheap and keeps your insurance history continuous. Never let a policy cancel for non-payment; set up autopay or calendar reminders.

6. Can small claims raise my rate?

Yes. Insurers share claim information through industry databases, so a new company can see claims you filed with an old one. Several small claims in a few years can raise your price more than one bigger claim.

What to do: for small damage that costs only a little more than your deductible, get a repair quote first. Sometimes paying out of pocket costs less over time than the price increase after a claim. Ask your insurer how they treat small claims before you file.

7 and 8. Age, experience and marital status

Young drivers and newly licensed drivers usually pay the most. Prices often drop as you build years of experience without accidents. Many insurers also price married drivers lower than single drivers.

Some states limit the use of gender or other personal factors. Your age is out of your hands, but you can tell your insurer right away when your life changes: marriage, a teen moving out, or reaching an age where rates usually drop.

9. Is your deductible set too low?

Your deductible is the amount you pay before insurance pays for damage to your own car. A lower deductible means a higher monthly price.

Raising it can lower your bill, but only do it if you could pay that amount tomorrow without borrowing. If a surprise repair bill would put you in debt, a higher deductible is the wrong move for you.

10. Does the way you pay change the price?

Often, yes. Many insurers add a small fee for each monthly payment. Paying for six or twelve months at once, signing up for autopay, or choosing paperless billing can each lower the total. Ask your insurer to list every payment option and its full cost.

11. Who else is on your policy?

Every driver in your household can affect your price. A teen driver, or someone with tickets or accidents, can raise it a lot. Some insurers let you exclude a household member who never drives your car. Ask how it works in your state, and understand that an excluded driver would not be covered if they did drive it.

12. Are you missing discounts?

Discounts are rarely added automatically. Ask about each of these by name:

• Bundling home or renters insurance with auto
• Good student (for young drivers with good grades)
• Defensive driving course
• Anti-theft devices and safety features
• Low mileage
• Loyalty, military, professional or alumni groups

How to check what is raising your rate

Follow these steps once a year, or after any big life change:

1. Get your declarations page. It lists your coverage, drivers, cars, mileage and discounts.

2. Check every detail. Address, mileage, drivers and car use (commute vs. pleasure) should be correct.

3. Ask your insurer directly: "Which factors are raising my rate the most?" Many will tell you. If your price went up because of your credit, federal law requires the insurer to send you a notice explaining it.

4. Pull your free credit reports and fix any errors.

5. Get at least three quotes from different companies with the same coverage limits, so you compare fairly.

When should you talk to a professional?

This article is general information, not advice for your personal situation. Talk to a licensed insurance agent or broker before you lower your coverage limits, drop collision or comprehensive coverage, or exclude a driver. Cutting coverage to save money can leave you paying a large bill out of pocket after an accident. If you think an insurer treated you unfairly, contact your state insurance department; every state has one, and they handle consumer complaints for free.

No single change will lower your rate by a set amount. Results depend on your state, your insurer and your history.

Your next step

Today, find your declarations page (it's usually in your insurer's app or email) and check three things: your address, your yearly mileage, and your list of discounts. If any of them is wrong or missing, call your insurer and ask them to update it. Then set a reminder one month before your renewal date to get three fresh quotes.

FAQ

Can my credit score raise my car insurance even with a clean record?

In most states, yes. Insurers use a credit-based insurance score to set prices. California, Hawaii and Massachusetts do not allow it for auto rates, and other states have their own limits.

Does a not-at-fault claim raise my insurance?

It can, depending on your insurer and state. Ask your insurer how they treat not-at-fault and small claims before you file one.

How often should I compare car insurance quotes?

At least once a year, about a month before renewal, and after any big change like moving, marriage, a new car or a change in how much you drive.

Should I raise my deductible to save money?

Only if you could pay the full deductible right away without borrowing. A licensed agent can help you weigh the savings against the risk.

Educational content, not personalized financial advice. Sources cited where applicable.