Your First Car Insurance Claim After an Accident, Explained

Sarah Mitchell

Sarah Mitchell writes about insurance basics and consumer comparisons. Insurance enthusiast 12 years. Texas-based.

Visual representation of the voice · not a photographic portrait

Quick answer: Report the accident to your insurer quickly, get a claim number, and work with the adjuster who inspects the damage and decides fault. The at-fault driver's insurer usually pays; if it was you, your collision coverage pays minus your deductible.↗ Share on X

When you file your first insurance claim after a car accident, the process usually goes like this: you report the claim to your insurer, a claims adjuster is assigned, the adjuster reviews the damage and decides who was at fault, and then the insurer pays for covered repairs or medical bills minus your deductible. Your own insurer pays if you were at fault or if you have the right coverage. The other driver's insurer pays if they were at fault. The whole thing can take from a couple of weeks for a simple fender bender to many months when there are injuries or a fight over fault.

Below is what happens at each step, what you should do, and the common mistakes that slow a first claim down or cost people money.

*This article is general information, not legal or financial advice. Insurance rules change from state to state and from policy to policy. If anyone was hurt, if fault is disputed, or if the insurer denies your claim, talk to a licensed insurance agent or an attorney in your state.*

What should you do at the scene before any claim?

READ ALSOHow to Compare Car Insurance Quotes in 30 Minutes Flat →Car insurance quotes: the 9 numbers to compare first →Comparing Car Insurance Quotes? Check These 8 Things First →

The claim starts at the scene, even though you file it later. What you collect in the first half hour makes everything easier.

1. Get safe first. Move to a safe spot if you can, turn on hazard lights, and check for injuries. Call 911 if anyone is hurt.

2. Call the police when the law in your state requires it, or when there is real damage or any injury. Ask for the report number.

3. Swap information with the other driver: name, phone, driver's license number, plate number, insurance company, and policy number.

4. Take photos of both cars, the plates, the road, traffic signs, skid marks, and any injuries. Take more than you think you need.

5. Get witness names and phone numbers. A neutral witness can decide a fault dispute.

6. Do not argue about fault. Stick to facts. Saying "it was my fault" at the scene can be used later, even if the facts show otherwise.

When and how do you file the claim?

Report the accident to your insurer as soon as you reasonably can, ideally the same day or the next day. Most policies say you must give "prompt" notice. Waiting weeks can give the company a reason to question or deny the claim.

You can usually file in three ways:

• through the insurer's mobile app, which often lets you upload photos right away
• by phone, using the claims number on your insurance card
• through your agent, if you bought the policy from a local agent

Have this ready before you call:

• your policy number
• date, time, and exact location of the accident
• the other driver's information
• the police report number
• your photos and witness details
• a short, factual description of what happened

You will get a claim number. Write it down. You will use it for every call and email from now on.

Whose insurance pays: yours or theirs?

READ ALSOHow to Compare Auto Insurance Quotes Without Overpaying →How to Compare Auto Insurance and Save Money Fast →How to Compare Auto Insurance: A Step-by-Step Guide →

This depends on who was at fault and on the type of state you live in.

A few terms explained in plain words:

• Liability coverage pays for damage you cause to other people. It does not fix your own car.
• Collision coverage fixes your own car after a crash, no matter who caused it.
• Comprehensive coverage fixes your car after things that are not a crash with another car: theft, hail, animals, falling trees.
• Personal injury protection (PIP) pays your own medical bills, and is required in no-fault states.

If you only have liability coverage and the accident was your fault, your policy will pay the other driver but will not pay to fix your car. Many first-time claimants learn this the hard way.

What does the claims adjuster do?

An adjuster is the insurance company's employee (or hired contractor) who investigates the claim and decides how much to pay. Expect the adjuster to:

1. Call you within a few days to take your statement. They may record it. Answer truthfully and stick to what you know. If you are not sure of something, say "I'm not sure."

2. Inspect the damage. Many insurers now ask for photos through an app. Others send an appraiser or ask you to visit a drive-in claims center.

3. Write an estimate of repair costs.

4. Decide fault, using the police report, statements, photos, and witnesses.

5. Make an offer or approve repairs.

If the other driver's insurer calls you, you can give basic facts, but you do not have to give a recorded statement to them. Many people choose to let their own insurer handle that contact.

How does the deductible work?

The deductible is the part of the repair bill you pay yourself before insurance pays the rest. It is listed on your policy's declarations page, usually as an amount like $500 or $1,000.

Here is an example:

• Repair estimate: $3,200
• Your collision deductible: $500
• Insurance pays: $2,700
• You pay the shop: $500

Two things people often miss:

• If the other driver was at fault, their liability coverage pays and you usually do not pay your deductible. If your own insurer pays first to speed things up, it may try to get the money back from the other insurer. This process is called subrogation. If it succeeds, you may get your deductible back.
• If the damage is less than the deductible, filing through your own collision coverage pays you nothing. You may still need to report the accident, because many policies require it.

What if the insurer says your car is totaled?

A car is "totaled" when repairs would cost more than the car is worth, or close to it. Each state and insurer uses its own rules for the cutoff.

If your car is totaled, the insurer pays the actual cash value: what your car was worth just before the crash, minus your deductible. That is not what you paid for it, and it is not the cost of a brand-new car.

If you still owe money on a car loan, the payout goes to the lender first. If you owe more than the car is worth, gap insurance covers the difference, but only if you bought it.

If the offer seems low, you can push back:

1. Ask for the valuation report in writing.

2. Look up similar cars for sale near you, with the same year, model, trim, and mileage.

3. Send those listings to the adjuster with a written request to review the value.

4. Mention recent repairs or new tires, with receipts.

How can you avoid a delayed or denied claim?

Most first-claim problems come from a few avoidable mistakes:

• Waiting too long to report the accident.
• Guessing in your statement instead of saying you do not know.
• Missing documents, like the police report or repair receipts.
• Letting repairs start before the adjuster approves them, unless the insurer tells you it is fine.
• Signing a release before you know the full extent of your injuries. A release usually ends your right to ask for more money later.
• Not keeping records. Keep a simple log of every call: date, name of the person, and what they said.

Will filing a claim raise your premium?

It might. An at-fault accident often leads to a higher premium at your next renewal. A claim where you were not at fault is less likely to raise your rate, but rules vary by state and by company. Some policies include "accident forgiveness" for a first accident. Check your policy documents or ask your agent before you decide whether to file a small claim yourself or pay out of pocket.

When should you get professional help?

Call a licensed professional instead of handling it alone when:

• anyone was injured, even slightly
• the other driver's insurer says you were at fault and you disagree
• your claim is denied and you think it should be covered
• the settlement offer does not cover your medical bills
• the adjuster stops returning calls for weeks

A personal injury attorney can review an injury claim, and many offer a free first meeting. Your state's department of insurance also takes complaints about how insurers handle claims, and filing a complaint there costs nothing.

Your next step

Open your insurance app or find your policy's declarations page today, before you ever need it. Write down three things on a note in your phone: your claims phone number, your collision deductible, and whether you have uninsured motorist coverage. If you find you only have liability coverage on a car you could not afford to replace, call your agent and ask for a quote to add collision.

FAQ

How soon should I file a claim after an accident?

As soon as you reasonably can, ideally the same or next day. Most policies require prompt notice, and long delays can create problems with your claim.

Do I pay my deductible if the other driver was at fault?

Usually not, because their liability coverage pays. If your insurer pays first, it may recover the money from the other insurer and you may get your deductible back.

When should I talk to an attorney?

If anyone was injured, fault is disputed, the claim is denied, or the offer does not cover your bills, talk to a licensed attorney or insurance professional in your state.

Educational content, not personalized financial advice. Sources cited where applicable.